I agree with the latter. Binding spells are intermediate level spells; strong ones are advanced. The one you would like to perform is an intermediate because it's fairly easy to counter.
However, to do an evil eye associated binding makes it harder to perform properly and thus significantly reduces your rate of success with it. I would not advise it for one reason only- because it associates the evil eye, which, if done properly, has a very bad effect on the anatomy of the third eye and crown chakra. What I meant to say is that it harms the other one, if not you in the process.
Never do a binding that can harm another. My advice to you, friend, is that lesser is better in this case. Find an easier spell to perform and one that would not harm, only banish them away from you. A binding should be your third option. Try a banishing first. To proper bind someone requires more skill and you can get equal amount of success with a simpler banishing.
Best regards and good luck :)